Reform the justice system to fight hate crimes
Canada is one of the best countries in the world to be Jewish, but statistics show that the Jewish community nevertheless remains one of the most frequently targeted minorities for hate crime.
The Jewish community recognizes that physical security requires active partnerships with government and law enforcement. Measures that empower the community to have a greater role in ensuring its own safety – such as situational awareness training and security audits – are key to preventing hate crime.
Statistics Canada has found that the Jewish community was the most targeted religious minority for hate crimes, accounting for 70 percent of religiously motivated hate in 2023. Hate crimes against the Jewish population increased 71 percent from 2022 to 2023, and although the Jewish community accounts for less than 1 percent of Canada’s population, 19 percent of all hate crimes were motivated by antisemitism in 2023. Synagogues and Jewish institutions are at risk of attack by violent extremists.
Recommendations
- Instructing intelligence services and local and national law enforcement organizations to designate community “point people” to liaise with the organized Jewish community. These officers will provide the Jewish community with timely information on threats, security developments, and best practices, and respond to emerging community concerns.
- Using the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, establishing a government-mandated definition of antisemitic “hate crimes” as the uniform, national standard to determine what constitutes a hate-motivated crime and to inform law enforcement’s approach to hate crime investigations and laying of charges.
- Creating dedicated hate crime units within all law enforcement services across the country, including resources and training to address the unique features of hate-inspired crime and ensuring currently established hate crime units are adequately equipped and trained to respond to hate.
- Enhancing training for law enforcement, Crown Attorneys, Attorneys General, and the judiciary regarding antisemitism, how to recognize it, and appropriate responses to incidents of antisemitism, including thorough investigations of suspected hate crimes and laying of criminal charges.
- Equipping law enforcement and intelligence services with the tools needed to combat extremism.
- Develop directives to guide attorneys general in the exercise of consent required to initiate proceedings under sections 318 and 319(2) and (2.1) of the Criminal Code so that the provisions are applied consistently.
- Increasing resources for law enforcement, Crown Attorneys, and judges to ensure they receive sufficient training on how to apply existing laws to effectively address online hate.